Running a Shopify store can be exciting, but dealing with high-risk orders is a challenge every merchant dreads. From my experience, these orders, if not handled properly, can lead to chargebacks and lost revenue, not to mention the impact on your store’s reputation. 

To help you protect your business, in this article, I’ll walk you through the basic-to-advanced information of identifying, managing, and minimizing Shopify high risk orders so that order management can no longer be an issue of your online store.

What is a high risk order on Shopify?

A Shopify order might be classified as high-risk if any of the transactions (using transaction monitoring tools) or user data raises concerns. For example, the high risk orders Shopify may include:

• Shipping address differs from billing address 
• Unknown customer’s high-value orders 
• Purchases using stolen credit cards
• An IP address refers to Tor or a proxy.

Consequences of processing high risk orders on Shopify

I can’t even count the times I’ve been burned by processing Shopify fraud risk orders – it’s like no matter how careful you are, one slip-up can lead to chargebacks, lost money, and a ton of stress. From my experience plus other merchant’s issues, here are some of the major consequences to your business if you try to process a high risk order Shopify:

• Financial Losses from Chargebacks: High-risk orders often lead to chargebacks, which result in lost revenue and additional fees. Frequent chargebacks can quickly drain resources and reduce profitability.
• Account Suspension or Termination: Frequent high-risk transactions may lead to account suspensions or terminations, disrupting business operations and requiring costly alternatives.
• Brand Reputation Damage: Fraudulent orders and chargebacks can harm your reputation, leading to a loss of customer trust and future business.
• Inventory and Operational Costs: Fraudulent orders lead to lost inventory and added shipping and handling expenses, which accumulate over time.
• Legal and Compliance Risks: High-risk transactions involving stolen credit cards can lead to costly legal issues and damage your credibility.

How to identify Shopify high risk orders?

From my experience, high-risk Shopify orders often come with red flags like mismatched billing and shipping addresses or unusually large quantities for a first-time customer. I always pay extra attention when an order feels “too good to be true” because it’s usually where the trouble starts.

If you sell products or services online, keep an eye out for these potential symptoms of fraud:

• Shopping for the First Time: If you want to build your business, you’ll need a consistent supply of new customers. However, new clients may introduce additional dangers, particularly if the first-time shopper possesses other high-risk qualities.
• Struggling to offer Personal Information: Genuine consumers may easily and properly offer personal information. Fraudsters may mispronounce names or hesitate to examine their alternatives before responding.
• A fraudster may not pay attention to details when buying: For example, the buy may contain items of various styles, sizes, and genders.
• Unusual IP Addresses: Keep an eye on purchases from IP addresses that appear suspicious or unusual. Multiple orders from the same IP address but using separate credit cards
• Focusing on Shipping Details: Fraudsters want their stolen products to be sent before the scheme is discovered. They will most likely be interested in how fast the order will be completed and transported.

How to deal with Shopify high risk orders?

Dealing with high-risk orders on Shopify is essential to avoid fraud and protect your revenue. Here are some effective ways for you to handle these high-risk Shopify orders:

• Review the Order Carefully: Check for common red flags like mismatched billing and shipping addresses, unusual order sizes, or multiple failed payment attempts. Take time to assess the risk level before proceeding.
• Contact the Customer: Reach out via phone or email to verify order details. Legitimate customers usually respond quickly, while fraudsters may avoid contact. Politely ask for confirmation of their shipping address and payment method.
• Limit High-Risk Regions: If you notice repeated fraud from specific regions, consider restricting shipments to these areas. You can adjust shipping settings in Shopify to reduce exposure to high-risk regions.
• Implement a Chargeback Protection Service: Look into third-party services or apps that offer chargeback protection. These services help cover losses from fraudulent transactions, and offer added peace of mind.
• Cancel the Order if Needed: If the risk seems too high and you’re unable to verify the order, it’s often best to cancel. Shopify allows you to cancel orders easily, and it’s better to miss a sale than risk a costly chargeback.

Top 5 apps to deal with Shopify high risk orders

I’ve been in situations where dealing with high-risk orders on Shopify felt like navigating a minefield—stressful and confusing. That’s why I’ve rounded up the top 5 apps that can seriously make handling those tricky orders so much easier.

	Vendor	Ratings	Key features	Download
FraudBlock Fraud Prevention	ShopFox	4.4/5 ⭐	Real-time fraud detectionCustomizable alertsTransaction monitoring	Get App
Beacon Fraud Protection	Lizuna KK	4.5/5 ⭐	Comprehensive fraud monitoringMulti-layered securityAutomated threat detection	Get App
Fraud Judge Fraud Prevention	Pluginhost B.V.	4.8/5 ⭐	Real-time transaction analysisScore-based fraud evaluationGlobal fraud database	Get App
Blockify Fraud Country Blocker	Blockify	4.9/5 ⭐	Country-specific transaction blockingReal-time risk assessmentCustomizable block lists	Get App
Shopify Flow	Shopify	3.7/5 ⭐	Custom workflow automationFraud detection triggersIntegration with apps and services	Get App

FraudBlock Fraud Prevention

Overview

I’ve used FraudBlock, and it’s really user-friendly. The app gives me peace of mind by keeping my transactions secure. It’s straightforward to set up, and I appreciate how it quickly flags any suspicious activity. The dashboard is easy to navigate, and I can track my fraud prevention stats with just a few clicks.

Best for: Small business owners and online service providers

Key features:

• Dashboard analytics
• AI-based fraud scoring
• Historical data analysis
• Integration with payment gateways
• Customer support access

Beacon Fraud Protection

Overview

Using Beacon has been a great experience for me. The app is like having a watchful eye over my transactions. I love how it provides detailed reports about potential threats. The interface is clean, and I can quickly understand what’s happening with my account.

Best for: E-commerce businesses and financial institutions

Key features:

• User-friendly dashboard
• Customizable fraud prevention rules
• Historical fraud trend analysis
• Integration capabilities
• 24/7 customer support

Fraud Judge Fraud Prevention

Overview

Fraud Judge has made it easy for me to protect my online store. The setup was quick, and the system worked quietly in the background, alerting me when something seemed off. The insights it provides are very useful, helping me make informed decisions about transactions.

Best for: Companies handling sensitive customer data, payment processors, and businesses that rely on subscriptions

Key features:

• Machine learning technology
• Easy integration with shopping carts
• Comprehensive reporting
• Customizable fraud settings
• Responsive customer service

Blockify Fraud Country Blocker

Overview

Blockify has been a lifesaver for me. It’s straightforward to use and effectively blocks transactions from high-risk countries. I appreciate how I can easily customize the settings to match my business needs. The app gives me a sense of security, knowing that I can prevent fraud before it happens.

Best for: E-commerce platforms, merchants, and businesses with international customers

Key features:

• Detailed analytics reports
• Simple integration with existing systems
• Alert notifications
• User-friendly interface
• Ongoing updates for fraud trends

Shopify Flow

Overview

Shopify Flow has transformed how I manage my online store. It automates many of my daily tasks, allowing me to focus on growing my business. The app helps me set up custom workflows to catch potential fraud, making my operations smoother and more secure.

Best for: Small to medium-sized businesses and retailers

Key features:

• Easy-to-use visual workflow builder
• Real-time notifications
• Data-driven insights
• Multi-channel support
• Scalability options

Tips for managing Suspicious Orders, Chargebacks and Disputes

In case you encounter several suspicious high-risk of fraud detected cases, I would like to introduce some realistic tips to instruct you exactly what to do with high risk orders Shopify

Suspicious orders

When reviewing potentially fraudulent orders, consider the following factors:

Order Details:

• Billing and Shipping Addresses: Check for inconsistencies or unusual patterns. Mismatched addresses can be a red flag.
• Order Amount: Unusually large or small orders may warrant closer scrutiny.
• Product Type: Some products are more prone to fraud (e.g., high-value electronics and gift cards).
• Order Frequency: Frequent orders from the same customer can be suspicious.

Customer Information:

• Verify Customer Details: Cross-check the provided information. Look for discrepancies in names, emails, or phone numbers.
• Order History: Check the customer’s past orders to see if there have been any previous chargebacks or suspicious transactions.
• IP Address Location: Compare the customer’s IP address with the billing and shipping locations.

Payment Method:

• Credit Card Verification: Ensure the credit card details match the customer’s information.
• High-Risk Countries: Be cautious with orders from countries known for high fraud rates.
• Unusual Payment Methods: Watch out for prepaid cards or virtual currencies.

Chargebacks and Disputes

Business can be frustrating when dealing with chargebacks and disputes; here are some tips for you:

• Understand Chargeback Codes: Identify the reason code to tailor your response effectively.
• Use Shopify’s Fraud Analysis: Review flagged high-risk orders to prevent potential chargebacks.
• Clearly Display Policies: Ensure refund, return, and shipping policies are accessible to prevent misunderstandings.
• Gather Strong Evidence: Include proof of purchase, shipping documentation, and customer communication for each dispute.
• Respond Quickly: Submit all required documentation promptly to meet Shopify’s response deadline.
• Accurate Product Descriptions: Use detailed images and specs to avoid “not as described” chargebacks.
• Promote Customer Service First: Encourage customers to reach out before filing a dispute to resolve issues directly.
• Require Signature for Expensive Orders: Obtain delivery signatures to confirm receipt, especially for high-value items.
• Use Shopify’s Chargeback Protection: If eligible, this can cover fraudulent chargebacks through Shopify Payments.
• Analyze Patterns and Improve: Identify recurring issues (like shipping delays) and make improvements to reduce chargebacks.

FAQs

1. What is a high-risk order on Shopify?

A high-risk order is flagged as potentially fraudulent, often due to mismatched addresses, high order values, or unusual customer behavior.

2. How does Shopify identify high-risk orders?

Shopify uses its fraud analysis tool to assess risk based on various factors like IP location, payment method, and customer details.

3. Should I cancel all high-risk orders on Shopify?

Not necessarily. It’s best to verify the order first by contacting the customer or using additional verification methods.

4. What are some tools to help manage high-risk orders?

Tools like Shopify Flow, Fraudblock, and Blockify are popular for detecting and managing high-risk orders on Shopify.

5. How can I reduce chargebacks from high-risk orders?

Using fraud detection tools, verifying customer details, and maintaining clear return policies can help prevent chargebacks.

Final words

Dealing with Shopify high risk orders comes down to identifying red flags, using fraud detection tools, and staying proactive in your approach. Protecting your store from fraud is essential to maintaining both revenue and customer trust. Take charge by implementing these strategies today—your business and bottom line will be better for it.

Related Posts:

• Optimize your Shopify homepage SEO
• How to Drive Traffic to Shopify store?
• Where to find Shopify SEO Help?
• 5 Best Payment Gateways for High-Risk Businesses